Ethereum

No one

Gary

Coin

July’s news that the California Department of Motor Vehicles <a href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/california-dmv-blockchain-avalanche-title-transfers">would move vehicle titles</a> to an Avalanche (<a href="https://cointelegraph.com/avalanche-price-index">AVAX</a>) subnet has all the hallmarks of innovation theater, the kind that is counterproductive to crypto adoption.
The value of using blockchain for this kind of application is debatable. Years ago, I too was a fan of using blockchain tech for provenance. But after watching countless valiant efforts (like <a href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/blockchain-based-supply-chain-platform-canned-by-ibm-and-maersk">TradeLens</a>) flounder and being forced to contemplate why, I’ve come to believe any blockchain that’s controlled by a single entity or a handful of legally bound affiliates is just a bad database. 
The standard argument in favor of this type of solution states that moving data on-chain improves traceability and transparency. But you can get those benefits from vanilla digitization and services like Carfax have been around for years. Ironically, this particular implementation is on a private subnet.
Related: <a href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/ethereum-gas-fees-too-low-or-high-no-one-can-decide">Ethereum gas fees: Too low or too high? No one can decide</a>
Permissionless networks like Bitcoin (<a href="https://cointelegraph.com/bitcoin-price">BTC</a>) and Ethereum (<a href="https://cointelegraph.com/ethereum-price">ETH</a>) are more than fancy databases. They are self-contained systems with embedded property rights that even the most powerful participants cannot interfere with. A government or consortium run permissioned chain does not, and cannot, offer such a feature. 
<figure>
 <img src="https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2024-08/5b6923f2-4e5c-43c3-8dd5-cfe11f20abf7.jpg" alt="California DMV putting vehicle titles on a subnet is innovation theater" title="">
 <figcaption style="text-align: center;">
 Ava Labs announced in July that the California DMV was putting vehicle titles on a private subnet. Source: <a href="https://x.com/AvaLabs/status/1818305633277673609" target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow">X</a>
 </figcaption>
</figure>
This is why the most successful blockchain applications revolve around fungible native assets: everything we need to determine who owns a Bitcoin&nbsp;exists within the system. Blockchain has also proved useful for expanding access and functionality for fungible reference assets like stablecoins. Circle doesn’t care who owns USD Coin (<a href="https://cointelegraph.com/usdc-price-index">USDC</a>), except in the most extreme cases. We tolerate the rare act of censorship because of benefits like use in smart contracts and inclusion in <a href="https://cointelegraph.com/defi-101/defi-a-comprehensive-guide-to-decentralized-finance">decentralized finance (DeFi)</a>.
Vehicle titles are different. They are both non-fungible and registered — each car must belong to a person. There is no possible future where vehicle ownership is handed over to smart contracts. First, this would be illegal. Second, car ownership is also impacted by external factors like traffic violations or unpaid debt. Five years ago I would have argued such data could be fed to a smart contract by an oracle. Now, I realize that doing so would be pointless because the DMV would reserve the right to intervene. It would reverse transfers it didn’t like, which is a good thing, lest hackers realize they can now steal cars legally.
Related: <a href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/gary-gensler-hurting-little-guys-for-wall-street">Gary Gensler is hurting the little guys for Wall Street</a>
Crypto nerds like me often talk about desirable system features like censorship resistance, liveness, and safety. What these mean for lay people is that a good network is one that doesn’t discriminate, is always on, and never changes its mind — those actions are bugs in payments and atomic swaps. But they are features for a government agency, we want the DMV to control vehicle transfers. Writing the trailing result on a slow database with a lot of cryptographic bloat it doesn’t use adds little.
That’s not to say the DMV shouldn’t digitize, speed up title transfers, and offer greater transparency. It also doesn’t mean consortiums of different states and their affiliated entities can’t build shared infrastructure for provenance of all sorts of driving-related data, including VINs, proof of insurance, and driver’s licenses. The financial services industry has been building this kind of thing for centuries. It just means using a blockchain to do either is a waste of time and distraction from true innovation. 
What might that look like? How about allowing vehicle owners to get zero-knowledge proof of ownership on a public chain, to be used in a self-sovereign reputation system that integrates with DeFi? Much harder to build than dumping a bunch of VINs on a private subnet, but that’s what makes it worthwhile. 
<div>
 <div style="background: rgb(239, 239, 239); border: 1px solid rgb(204, 204, 204); padding: 10px;">
 Omid Malekan is a guest columnist for Cointelegraph, an adjunct professor at Columbia Business School and the author of Re-Architecting Trust: The Curse of History and the Crypto Cure for Money, Markets, and Platforms.
 </div>
</div>
This article is for general information purposes and is not intended to be and should not be taken as legal or investment advice. The views, thoughts, and opinions expressed here are the author’s alone and do not necessarily reflect or represent the views and opinions of Cointelegraph.

California DMV putting vehicle titles on a subnet is innovation theater

Cointelegraph

Other articles published on Aug 22, 2024

Lisk and Gerakan Nasional 1000 Startup Digital Unveil Ignit3

XRP and ADA Are Cooked – Here is Why Traders Are Turning to BLASTUP for 1000X Gains

Binance Labs New Investment: What is MyShell?

Bringing Legends to the Metaverse: Experience Iconic Moments with CEEK

Bitcoin Will Surge If Trump Wins The Election: Tom Lee

Altcoins Flash Bullish Signal: Falling Wedge Breakout Looms

Join our free newsletter for daily crypto updates!