Solana

While presiding wisdom suggests that a Solana exchange-traded fund isn’t happening anytime soon, one executive says a long-closed crypto fraud case from 2018 could give a hint on how to turn things around.&nbsp;
VanEck’s Head of Digital Assets Research, Matthew Sigel, recently wrote on X that his firm still believes SOL is a commodity, much like Bitcoin (<a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/bitcoin-price" rel="null" target="null" text="null">BTC</a>) and Ether (<a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/ethereum-price" rel="null" target="null" text="null">ETH</a>). This classification is necessary for Solana (<a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/solana-price-index" rel="null" target="null" text="null">SOL</a>) to get its own crypto ETF in the United States.&nbsp;
“This belief is informed by evolving legal perspectives, where courts and regulators have begun to recognize that certain crypto assets may function as securities in primary markets but behave more like commodities in secondary markets,” he wrote on Aug. 20.&nbsp;
Sigel referred to a six-year-old, now-closed court case against My Big Coin, a fraudulent crypto payments company.&nbsp;
<figure>
 <img alt="2018 fraud case could hold key to Solana ETF approval: VanEck exec" name="" src="https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2024-08/Matthew%20Sigel%20commodities%20argument">
 <figcaption style="text-align: center;">
 Source: <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://x.com/matthew_sigel/status/1825979323871859065" rel="null" target="null" text="null">Matthew Sigel</a>
 </figcaption>
</figure>
The Commodities, Futures and Trading Commission charged the firm’s founders in 2018 with fraudulently selling customers a “My Big Coin” token and lying about its usage and value, saying it breached the Commodities Exchange Act.&nbsp;
The defendants attempted to dismiss the case, arguing that the My Big Coin (MBC) token was not a commodity because <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/explained/what-are-ether-futures-etfs-and-how-do-they-work" rel="null" target="null" text="null">futures contracts</a> that reference it do not exist.&nbsp;
However, the judge <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/7820-18" rel="null" target="null" text="null">rejected</a> the argument, noting that My Big Coin is a “virtual currency” in the same way that Bitcoin is, making an analogy with natural gas.
This was enough for the CFTC to allege MBC is a commodity, allowing the case to go ahead.&nbsp;
The founder was later convicted by a federal jury in 2022 and later sentenced to 100 months in prison and ordered to pay $7.6 million to victims of his scheme. Sigel added:
<blockquote>
 “This same logic could apply to digital assets like Solana, and could shape the future of ETF regulation.”
</blockquote>
But in the near term, other ETF commentators are less optimistic.&nbsp;
<h2 id="strong-solana-etfs-have-snowball-s-chance-in-hell-strong">Solana ETFs have “snowball’s chance in hell”</h2>
Bloomberg ETF analyst Eric Balchunas commented that after Cboe reportedly removed its 19b-4 filings for Solana ETFs from its website, the ETFs now have a “snowball’s chance in hell of approval.”
On Aug. 16, reports <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://x.com/SummersThings/status/1824596192929464581" rel="null" target="null" text="null">emerged</a> that Cboe had removed the <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/learn/spot-ethereum-etf" rel="null" target="null" text="null">19b-4 filings</a> for two prospective <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/solana-etfs-significant-demand-sygnum-research-head" rel="null" target="null" text="null">Solana ETFs</a> from its website’s “Pending Rule Changes” page.&nbsp;
Some have <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://x.com/scottmelker/status/1825691945366131136" rel="null" target="null" text="null">speculated</a> the United States Securities and Exchange Commission <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://x.com/SGJohnsson/status/1824648846732828776" rel="null" target="null" text="null">rejected</a> the filings before they could even undergo formal consideration due to the regulator’s “concerns” over Solana’s classification as a security.
<figure>
 <img alt="2018 fraud case could hold key to Solana ETF approval: VanEck exec" name="" src="https://s3.cointelegraph.com/uploads/2024-08/eric%20balchunas%20flow%20chart%20tweet">
 <figcaption style="text-align: center;">
 Source: <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://x.com/EricBalchunas/status/1825919807440458196" rel="null" target="null" text="null">Eric Balchunas</a>
 </figcaption>
</figure>
“Yes, near-zero chance in 2024, and if Harris wins, there’s prob near-zero chance in 2025 too. Only hope IMO is if Trump wins,” said Balchunas in response to a comment on his original post.&nbsp;
“Solana ETF not happening anytime soon under the current administration,” <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://x.com/NateGeraci/status/1793426041693938163" rel="null" target="null" text="null">wrote</a> ETFStore president Nate Geraci in an earlier X post on Aug. 17.
Geraci has previously argued that the approval of Solana ETFs would <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/solana-etfs-significant-demand-sygnum-research-head" rel="null" target="null" text="null">hinge on</a> Solana (<a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/solana-price-index" rel="null" target="null" text="null">SOL</a>) being classified as a commodity.&nbsp;
Related: <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/brazil-first-spot-solana-etf-launch" rel="null" target="null" text="null">Brazil poised to launch world’s first spot Solana ETF ahead of global markets</a>
Meanwhile, <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/solana-etf-still-play-despite-cboe-filing-removal-vaneck-exec" rel="null" target="null" text="null">Sigel also noted</a> that VanEck’s S-1 filing is “still in play” despite Cboe removing the 19b-4 on its website.&nbsp;
“Remember that Exchanges like Nasdaq &amp; CBOE file rule changes (19b-4) to list new ETFs. Issuers like VanEck are responsible for the prospectus (S-1). Ours remains in play.”
Cointelegraph reached out to Cboe Global Markets for comment.
Magazine: <a data-ct-non-breakable="null" href="https://cointelegraph.com/magazine/11-critical-moments-ethereum-history-that-made-eth-no2-blockchain/" rel="null" target="null" text="null">11 critical moments in Ethereum’s history that made it the No.2 blockchain</a>

2018 fraud case could hold key to Solana ETF approval: VanEck exec

Table of Contents

Cointelegraph

Other articles published on Aug 21, 2024

Bitcoin miner Bitfarms to acquire rival Stronghold Digital

Crypto Whale Lost $55M Worth DAI To A Phishing Attack

Render Token Price Prediction: Is Render Price Aiming For Bearish Pullback?

Tether Mints $3 Billion USDT in One Week: A Sign of Impending Crypto Rally?

Bybit to List $DOGS Token on August 26

Tether to Launch Dirham-Pegged Stablecoin in Partnership with UAE’s Phoenix Group

Join our free newsletter for daily crypto updates!