CoinMarketCap Research's first piece examines what's happening in the ongoing Celsius Network crisis — and how to use CoinMarketCap to do your own due diligence before investing.
In CoinMarketCap Research's first piece, we aim to examine the Celsius business model and platform to understand what went wrong leading up to the lending provider's suspension of user withdrawals. Will the platform potentially run the risk of liquidation that is set to send shockwaves in the entire crypto ecosystem? This is what the article will cover:
- Review of the Celsius platform - breakdown its business model and ecosystem to understand what went wrong.
- Assess the red flags happened over the past few weeks regarding Celsius’ liquidity and yield generating issue, re-assess how this will further impact the crypto market.
- What have we learned from this experience - review some basics on how to properly “Do Your Own Research” (DYOR) on any projects, and link it back to the tools and resources available on CoinMarketCap.
Join us in showcasing the cryptocurrency revolution, one newsletter at a time. Subscribe now to get daily news and market updates right to your inbox, along with our millions of other subscribers (that’s right, millions love us!) — what are you waiting for?
What Happened Leading up to Celsius' Suspension of User Funds
Before jumping into the analysis, here’s a primer on what happened in the still-unfolding Celsius crisis. On June 11, 2022, users were reportedly unable to login to the Celsius platform, adding on to rumors of a potential Celsius implosion and liquidity crisis that has been making circles over the past week.
In short, as Bitcoin and Ethereum continue to suffer drawdowns, it becomes harder for Celsius to remain solvent, as collateral value decreases.
Update: As of June 14, Celsius has topped up its colleteral across their loan positions. In their MarkerDAO WBTC vault, liquidation price has been lowered from $20,272 to $14,000. They have also added ETH collateral to their stETH position on Aave, although the falling stETH price has lowered the collateral ratio. However, its sizeable position on Compound, worth $420M, was largely untouched except for a repayment in $6.2M in DAI.
Part 1: Examining Celsius Business Model
1. Project team Preserves Its Own Self-Interest
One example of this is naming itself Celsius “network” with limited content on describing the network setup while having an entire section dedicated to showing an “executive team”. Celsius has a few founders, a CEO, a COO, a CTO, together with Marketing and Development departments. However, when deepdive on the key personnel’s background and experiences, there seems to be very little demonstrable track record.
2. Celsius Tokenomics Analysis
A deeper look at its tokenomics shows that 40% of the total CEL tokens were issued in the presale phase in Q4 2017 at $0.20 per token, and later Celsius performed a crowdsale of 10% of the total CEL tokens at $0.30 per token in March 2018.
Part 2: Key Missteps Made by Celsius
- June 12, 2022: Announcement: halting all withdrawals, transfers, and swaps on platform.
- 2021 market saw a few arbitrage opportunities between spot bitcoin and its futures and derivatives, i.e. GBTC trading at discount/premium and the bitcoin futures market in contango. This has allowed investors like Celsius to profit from these price differentials, and this arbitrage profit acted as the funding source for their yield products These opportunities then dried up as the market moved into 2022.
- To obtain additional yield to support its products, Celsius invested in a few risky assets (details). Following the Terra crash, the investors have become more cautious on the liquidity and solvency of these risky assets. Some started to question the Celsius setup, especially on its investment in Anchor’s yield farming and in Lido’s staked ETH (stETH).
- This series of events have led to a few bad outcomes for Celsius:
- it’s running out of liquidity;
- the staked ETH saw its value dropping 4.5% below ETH (supposed to be pegged with 1:1 ratio);
- Celsius was also on the verge of a margin call on 17,900 wrapped BTC
With all these challenges, Celsius has limited options but to gate the funds and halt withdrawals, swaps and transfers to prevent facing a “bank run” situation.
Crypto and Traditional Market Impact
This event, together with Friday's CPI release, has sent shock waves across the crypto market. Global markets have also experienced material price falls with major equities, fixed income, gold and other commodities all trending downwards.
We are still cautious as we see the crypto market not yet priced in the risk of contagion, meaning when the Celsius resumes its services, we are likely to see users rushing out to redeem. Other projects with similar lines of business like BlockFi, NEOX and so on, are also put under additional pressure and scrutiny.
Part 3: How To Utilise CMC Resources for “Doing Your Own Research”
CoinMarketCap already hosts a vast amount of content related to each project directly on our website. In addition to checking the prices and league tables, users can also:
- Check the Overview tab to gain a better understanding of the project, with links directly to its White Paper and official website, etc.
- Read the Analysis tab and Ratings tab, for trading signals and in-depth report;
- Visit the Socials tab and News tab to review project announcements, discuss with other project fans, read related news and tech deep-dive articles.
- Head over to Alexandria to search for the technical articles and use learn-and-earn section to test your understanding.